Electrical Testing
The Path of Least Resistance

The Path of Least Resistance

Understanding how electricity flows through a circuit

One of the most dangerous ideas circulating in the electrical industry is that electricity follows the path of least resistance. But if it did, not a single one of our electronic gadgets would work.

This concept is not taught in any engineering school. In fact, it contradicts what is taught. Yet, you can hear this stated, even among electricians and engineers, as if it’s true. Not only is it stated, but it’s followed in practice.

We see it most often in grounding applications. You can walk into many plants and find a motor that is tied to a ground rod. Individually, ask each person in electrical maintenance department why there’s a ground rod connected to the motor. Ask them if that was done to eliminate differences of potential, and the odds are most of them will say yes. Same thing will probably happen if you ask the plant electrical engineer.

But is this what that connection actually does? You can answer this question by drawing out the circuit and applying Kirchoff’s Law of Parallel Circuits. That’s the same law that first year electrical students apply to determine the value of one resistor that’s in parallel with another resistor.

Let’s look at that first year problem, first. You have two 100 ohm resistors in parallel. What’s the total resistance? It’s 50 ohms. If you had only one 100 ohm resistor, the resistance would be 100 ohms. But add another, and it’s half the resistance. That’s because you added a parallel path and it’s flowing through not just one path but two. Using a water analogy, you double the total flow when you put a second four inch pipe in parallel with the first one.

If electricity actually took the path of least resistance, the answer would be 100 ohms. Since both paths are equal, electricity would arbitrarily go through either path. But that’s not what happens. It flows through both paths in inverse proportion to the resistances presented to it.

Current flows through all paths, not just the path of least resistance.

Grounding the motor does what, exactly? Well, that grounding connection is one of several parallel paths that electricity could take. The motor bearings are another. So is the operator who decides to put one foot on that ground rod and another on the motor, an act that puts his heart in a parallel current path with the motor.

Electricity tries to get back to its source. The impedance of the dirt between that ground rod and the supply transformer is much higher than the 100 ohms of the typical human body. If enough stray current is present, that operator could be electrocuted while standing on the ground rod.

By now, you may be forming a mental picture. Now put it on paper. Draw that motor and draw the circuits that exist in parallel with the motor grounding connection. Write in the ohmic values, and you can see that grounding connection is most certainly not eliminating differences of potential.

Hide comments

Comments

  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <blockquote> <br> <p>

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Publish