Voter Pushback Clouds the Outlook for America’s Data Center Boom

Voters approved dozens of measures constraining data center development, and newly elected governors have promised greater scrutiny. Analysts expect delays and new rules, but not a wholesale halt to construction.

Key Takeaways

  • Voters approved about 40 local measures aimed at constraining data center construction.
  • New governors in several states have pledged to slow development or impose a moratorium.
  • Analysts differ on the scale of regulatory risk, with estimates ranging from delays to restrictions affecting large shares of planned capacity.
  • Bernstein expects project fundamentals — such as tenant credit and developer experience — to outweigh political risk in determining which projects proceed.
  • The likely outcome is pauses, delays, and new regulations rather than an end to the data center boom.

United States mid-term election results may have settled speculation about individual candidate prospects, but they haven’t quelled uncertainty surrounding one of the campaign’s major themes: artificial intelligence and data centers.

The road ahead for both is now a bit more clouded – if only slightly. Successful ballot initiatives and a “Blue Wave” that changed governors and statehouses portend some pushback against unchecked expansion.

The election put more of a face on growing unease about AI generally. But it also carried a concrete message from voters about data centers: The torrid pace of their construction needs at least a second look. Voters across the country approved some 40 local measures constraining their buildout while many gubernatorial candidates channeling voter fears about the pace of development prevailed.

The telegraphing – that many people are worried, for many reasons, about the proliferation of the sprawling, power devouring structures – now seems clearer. Far less certain, however, is whether a resultant meaningful slowdown in data center construction is in store.

The uncertainty spawned by the election is keeping many watchers of the AI infrastructure phenomenon busy. If there’s any consensus, it seems to be that a speed bump is the most likely outcome, with moratoriums, extended reviews, and more conditions on development joining a host of additional, mostly economics-related factors affecting the fate of data center projects.

One assessment drawing attention comes from the investment bank Bernstein. As detailed in a recent Biggo Finance post, Bernstein’s post-election analysis predicts that moratoriums, new regulations and other elements of “political risk” will have a comparatively minor impact on the fate of planned datacenter projects.

Of 387GW of North American data center capacity now in the planning stage that Bernstein predicts will never be built – 66% of the 586GW total now on the drawing board –  the smallest, at just 28GW, will be attributable to “state political risk.” More impactful, it says, will be likely abandonment due to extended groundbreaking delays that signal problems, insufficient tenant credit, and inadequate developer strength/track record.

However, some of the 199GW balance likely to be built does face some regulatory risk, it says, because two-thirds of it are in 13 states that carry high regulatory risk. That could translate to groundbreaking delays due to moratoriums or similar roadblocks.

“Bernstein's estimates,” the Biggo post notes, “remind the market that while political risk is real, in a vast planning pool of 586GW, fundamental factors such as development stage, tenant credit, and developer qualifications are the bigger variables determining whether projects get built.”

Other investment firms that study the AI infrastructure build-out have different takes on the election’s impact. Among firm projections the Biggo Finance post highlights, Goldman Sachs sees state moratoriums affecting 45% of planned capacity; Morgan Stanley sees about 5% of projects shifting from 2028 to 2029; and J.P. Morgan estimates 55% of 96GW planned for 2028 facing new restrictions.

Another assessment of risk from mounting public pushback comes from Cleanview, which closely tracks data center infrastructure. On its face, it says, the election results don’t bode well for many planned projects since many are in states like Texas, New Mexico, Georgia, and Ohio where newly elected governors promised to at least slow the build-out (see Figure).

But the impact is likely to amount to pauses and delays mostly rather than wholesale scrapping of projects. The results, it says, “don’t signal the end of the data center boom. They will, however, likely bring a pause in some of the largest markets and new regulations across the country — even in traditionally laissez-faire states like Texas,” where the newly elected governor has promised a broad moratorium on new projects in a state that is among the leaders in new data center construction.

AI infrastructure interests, it’s clear, woke up to a new reality the day after the election. But the long term trajectory of continued expansion of the physical assets needed to power AI hasn’t likely changed. Developers are now on notice that more eyes are watching, a development that might ultimately help smooth the path forward for what has become a key component of the U.S. economy.

Importantly, some key stakeholders on the construction side of the build-out evidently see things working out favorably in the end. Post-election, an IBEW spokeperson who advised the newly elected Ohio governor, told the New York Times that “we are not going to see a dramatic downturn” in data center projects.

About the Author

Tom Zind

Freelance Writer

Zind is a freelance writer based in Lee’s Summit, Mo. He can be reached at [email protected].

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of EC&M, create an account today!